...by VOCAL ABILITY. Best to worst. In their prime
Keyshia Cole
Amerie
Ashanti
Tweet
Mya
Jazmine Sullivan
Keri Hilson
Fantasia
Alicia Keys
Fantasia
Jazmine
The others are debatable...
...All I know is Alicia Keys is LAST on my list.
Quote from: M-Rocka on June 11, 2025, 06:48:35 PMFantasia
Jazmine
The others are debatable...
...All I know is Alicia Keys is LAST on my list.
I'm adding "in their prime" to the OP
Quote from: Ulysses on June 11, 2025, 06:45:20 PM...by VOCAL ABILITY. Best to worst. In their prime
Keyshia Cole
Amerie
Ashanti
Tweet
Mya
Jazmine Sullivan
Keri Hilson
Fantasia
Alicia Keys
Fantasia/Jazmine
Tweet
Mya
Keri
The rest.
Jazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia
Mya
Keyshia
Keri
Amerie
Ashanti
:trannyjblige:
Quote from: DopeSoul. on June 11, 2025, 07:10:26 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia
Mya
Keyshia
Keri
Amerie
Ashanti
:trannyjblige:
This is actually my same exact order
Fantasía/ Jazmine
Tweet
Alicia
Mya
Keri
Ashanti
Keyshia
Amerie
Quote from: Ulysses on June 11, 2025, 07:35:12 PMQuote from: DopeSoul. on June 11, 2025, 07:10:26 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia
Mya
Keyshia
Keri
Amerie
Ashanti
:trannyjblige:
This is actually my same exact order
:traciandchelle:
Jazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Quote from: Gilgamesh. on June 11, 2025, 07:10:21 PMQuote from: Ulysses on June 11, 2025, 06:45:20 PM...by VOCAL ABILITY. Best to worst. In their prime
Keyshia Cole
Amerie
Ashanti
Tweet
Mya
Jazmine Sullivan
Keri Hilson
Fantasia
Alicia Keys
Fantasia/Jazmine
Tweet
Mya
Keri
The rest.
Accurate af!!!
Also - Tweet and Fantasia need a Tiny Desk
Quote from: DopeSoul. on June 11, 2025, 07:10:26 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia
Mya
Keyshia
Keri
Amerie
Ashanti
:trannyjblige:
Quote from: Harlem on June 11, 2025, 10:39:12 PMAlso - Tweet and Fantasia need a Tiny Desk
When Fanny was getting all that Color Purple buzz it would have been the perfect time.
Jazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia/Keyshia
Quote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Keri
Mya
Quote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Not Amerie perched last :plzstop:
Y'all just won't take y'all foot off her neck
Jazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Keyshia
Amerie
Mya
Keri
Alicia
Ashanti
I love em all in their own way really
Quote from: Dee on June 12, 2025, 09:39:12 AMJazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia/KeyshiaQuote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Keri
MyaQuote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Not Amerie perched last :plzstop:
Y'all just won't take y'all foot off her neck
It's what inspired the thread. I was thinking of the 2000's girls and was wondering if there were some bad singers out during that time in R&B. The only other bad singer that saw success during that time I could think of was Ashanti. So I was curious as to what people felt of these girls in that era.
I noticed the Ameries didn't respond though. So the silence says enough.
Quote from: Dee on June 12, 2025, 09:39:12 AMJazmine
Fantasia
Tweet
Alicia/Keyshia
Quote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Keri
Mya
Quote from: Nine on June 11, 2025, 08:44:55 PMJazmine
Fantasia
Mya
Tweet
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Ashanti
Amerie
Not Amerie perched last :plzstop:
Y'all just won't take y'all foot off her neck
fsdfdfsljfdsdfkldfs
I feel like I've heard better vocals from Ashanti then Amerie in the past few years
In their "primes", they were pretty even imo
I prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
Sorry to hear that
Quote from: Amazing on June 12, 2025, 05:55:43 PMI prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
We didn't say "who do you prefer?" We said "vocal ability"
You coulda added Truth Hurts and Blu Cantrell to make it more interesting :caramelapple:
Blu would be top tier of the list, honestly
I mainly stuck to the girls with not much vocal capabilities, but was curious also of what folks would think of a Fantasia VS Jazzy
but are you still not at peace with the fact that some people like Amerie or her voice :-D
Quote from: 𝖘𝖖𝖚𝖎𝖉 on June 13, 2025, 01:51:46 PMbut are you still not at peace with the fact that some people like Amerie or her voice :-D
Oh, take a look at the rankings. She's at the bottom tier of every list.
And we still fuck with her. NEXT!?
Quote from: Amazing on June 12, 2025, 05:55:43 PMI prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
!!!
Amerie definitely shouldn't be perched at the bottom.
Quote from: Dee on June 13, 2025, 07:38:56 PMQuote from: Amazing on June 12, 2025, 05:55:43 PMI prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
!!!
Amerie definitely shouldn't be perched at the bottom.
Well go ahead. Rank them. And let me see her perched above Jazzy and Fanny while you're at it
Quote from: Dee on June 13, 2025, 07:38:56 PMQuote from: Amazing on June 12, 2025, 05:55:43 PMI prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
!!!
Amerie definitely shouldn't be perched at the bottom.
I prefer Amerie's vocals over a lot of these girls but I recognize that she's one of the weakest on the list.
Fantasia
Jazmine
Tweet
Mya
Ashanti
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Amerie
Quote from: Dee on June 13, 2025, 07:38:56 PMQuote from: Amazing on June 12, 2025, 05:55:43 PMI prefer Amerie's voice over a lot of the gorls. PERIOD.
!!!
Amerie definitely shouldn't be perched at the bottom.
yes she should. She can't sing a lick BZBXBXBJXCKOCIF
If the list was based on whose voice/tone you prefer an argument in her favor would make sense. Otherwise... she's pretty awful technically
Quote from: Kaeli. on June 14, 2025, 11:33:03 AMFantasia
Jazmine
Tweet
Mya
Ashanti
Keri
Alicia
Keyshia
Amerie
Ddscs
U don't like DLicia??
Yall keep saying this but are afraid to put these ladies into an order
:omf:
Quote from: Ulysses on June 14, 2025, 07:58:25 PMYall keep saying this but are afraid to put these ladies into an order
ima need you to lower you voice and back the fuck up.
Quote from: Stunna Gor' on June 15, 2025, 01:44:01 AMQuote from: Ulysses on June 14, 2025, 07:58:25 PMYall keep saying this but are afraid to put these ladies into an order
ima need you to lower you voice and back the fuck up.
GSFSSFSGSGFSSGSGSTGGTT
Idc Amerie's vocals and harmonies on her debut were luscious and beautiful.
I do like off 🔑 singers like Mary though
:plzstop:
They make up for it in other ways with their tone, passion and great songs.
Quote from: Amazing on June 15, 2025, 11:31:06 PMIdc Amerie's vocals and harmonies on her debut were luscious and beautiful.
this is why I put Ashanti last
She never sounded this good in the studio
And live she always sounds likes it's her first time on the mic
Quote from: Amazing on June 15, 2025, 11:33:55 PMI do like off 🔑 singers like Mary though
:plzstop:
They make up for it in other ways with their tone, passion and great songs.
Well, one is a soul singer that gets lost in her performance and let's us feel her pain and love through her delivery. The other is just incapable of hitting the right notes but she's really trying.
I didn't know the gorls preferred Keysh' and Mya over Keri vocally.
HOMEWRECKER Keys I can understand since she was a top notch during her debut days