Home

[L0NZ.]

Which 2 can't sing???

[RAY7]

Which 2 can't sing???

gfcfhtdcdsdr
Wow is it that bad

[L0NZ.]

Oh ok cuz if u were confident in that, you would have just said who.

Carry on.

[RAY7]

What are you taking about?
I was clearly saying Janet and Madonna
But if Mariah is that bad to you that it's debatable then that hilarious and she must've really fallen off

[oph.]

well i was clearly speaking to a reasonably assumed context, and have been speaking to that this entire time.

challenge: ask most people you know what they consider "great artistry" to be

and tell me how many people tell you all they consider for that is how great someone's voice is.

that's all. i'll gladly eat egg if my assumptions are wrong or unreasonable.

again, i NEVER. ARGUED. what most people assume artistry entails.

then why are we even here

sdnsdnsds

if you agree that there's a pretty consistent idea of what "artistry" entails to most people?

let me take u back to what started our exchange:

that's you just making an assumption tho bby. all it said was category: artistry go. there were no specifications made.

 

jesus. you really do just wanna argue bvccccccc

i made that statement in response to this:

but i think the context of this thread was pointing more towards material. songs.

and we have people in here saying Whitney has the best voice but isn't the greatest artist
which speaks to...guess what: overall material.

so yes again, why are we here

"material" and "songs" speaks to a combination of vocals, themes/concepts, and overall musicality.
it's more general than "voice".

whats not clicking

you wanna argue so bad you don't even know what you're arguing anymore

reread my posts slowly. if you get, great. if you don't, God BLESS

 

[stillpretty]

wanting to argue wouldn't be asking you why are we arguing when you seem to agree with me

sfnsmjjsjnfnjsfjnf 

you agreed that there is a universal definition/consensus on what's implied when someone says "great artistry"

that was my point. there's literally nothing else to discuss

[FAMÈ]

Madonna, Whitney and Janet are all singles artist.

[Lazarus]

Correct me if I'm wrong but Whitney wasn't sitting down producing her vocals, crafting and stacking her backgrounds like Brandy does. I know Brandy had help but she was still at the forefront of her vocal producing, at least for most of her albums.

The perception of Whitney was that she goes to the studio, records the song in 30 minutes before heading to the mall before it closes.

Whitney did vocal production and arrangements. She just didn't pen lyrics. She is credited as a co-writer for Queen of the Night and few songs on her 2002's Just Whitney album.

[Lazarus]

Janet definitely can sing. She's not given enough credit for her background vocals/arrangements.

Only person among this group that can't sing is Madonna period.  But her music has always been interesting though.

[Lazarus]

Madonna, Whitney and Janet are all singles artist.

n

Definitely not.

[Ulysses]

2 of them can't sing and the other can't sing anymore
That's what they've done with their craft

And neither could whit toward the end of her career and she was still fairly young 

It's TORTURE sitting through the "I Look to You" album

[Ulysses]

All this back and forth because folks don't want to accept that Whit wasn't hanging with the more artistic girls

[RAY7]

2 of them can't sing and the other can't sing anymore
That's what they've done with their craft

And neither could whit toward the end of her career and she was still fairly young 

It's TORTURE sitting through the "I Look to You" album

even on that album she's doing more than Janet and Madonna ever could
and this is after years of cigarette smoking and coke.
They have no excuse

[stillpretty]

forbidden luh....
forbidden luh.

[Ulysses]

2 of them can't sing and the other can't sing anymore
That's what they've done with their craft

And neither could whit toward the end of her career and she was still fairly young 

It's TORTURE sitting through the "I Look to You" album

even on that album she's doing more than Janet and Madonna ever could
and this is after years of cigarette smoking and coke.
They have no excuse

Can't say I've ever heard Jans or Madonna this bad. Mariah came close a couple times, but still didn't manage to sound THIS bad.