Home

[Ulysses]

Well part of a "skilled" singer is being able to sing in that register...

[L0NZ.]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

[Lazarus]

 

[Lazarus]

[Ulysses]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

It sure does. Being able to do so is in training your vocal chords 

[Gilgamesh.]

You're both right. Every person a range that their voice "naturally" has, which is where contralto, soprano, tenor etc definitions come from. But, you can train your voice to sing higher/lower.

So, I wouldn't say Chante having a whistle register makes her skilled but I would say her still having a strong whistle register - at her age - is absolutely due to her skill. 

[RAY7]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

It sure does. Being able to do so is in training your vocal chords 

it is not. And honestly most vocal coaches tell singers not to do it

[Gilgamesh.]

Anyway, of all of these girls Fanny is the best singer, Tamia is the best vocalist 

[Ulysses]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

It sure does. Being able to do so is in training your vocal chords 

it is not. And honestly most vocal coaches tell singers not to do it

I don't know how to say this, but you're absolutely fucking WRONG. And relax. No one is saying Tamia isn't also a great singer

[RAY7]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

It sure does. Being able to do so is in training your vocal chords 

it is not. And honestly most vocal coaches tell singers not to do it

I don't know how to say this, but you're absolutely fucking WRONG. And relax. No one is saying Tamia isn't also a great singer

as someone that has actually studied this topic Im not
and I don't stan for Tamia
Just giving the knowledge that singing higher notes doesn't make a singer more skilled

[klappa.]

yea, chante

[Ulysses]

Hmm I don't think range has anything to do with skill

It sure does. Being able to do so is in training your vocal chords 

it is not. And honestly most vocal coaches tell singers not to do it

I don't know how to say this, but you're absolutely fucking WRONG. And relax. No one is saying Tamia isn't also a great singer

as someone that has actually studied this topic Im not
and I don't stan for Tamia
Just giving the knowledge that singing higher notes doesn't make a singer more skilled

We do a lil grade school project on it? Stfu

[The definition]

It's a tie between Chante and Tamia

[Vonc2002]

I have seen all of these ladies live (except keke) and they are really all great.  Fantasia is the best performer but chante and Tamia really are just WHEW. I didnt like Chante's song choices on that lil Asian shit but she definitely IS amazing without those whistle notes, let's be clear

[Justaway_]

WHEW!