Brandy/Darkchild vs Brandy/Timbaland

Started by Dr Naomi Campbell, August 20, 2020, 03:47:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

well which brandy bitch?

Brandy x Timbaland
26 (54.2%)
Brandy x Darkchild
22 (45.8%)

Total Members Voted: 47

Aamerie.

Quote from: Trey on August 21, 2020, 08:35:46 PM
Quote from: BorderL0NZ. on August 21, 2020, 07:18:58 PM
not B7 being in the trinity nnn

it is NOT better than NSN. Y'all are just getting a thirst quenched atm but ...
d

!!!!!! :dead: Lets revisit this mess in 2 years. Hell, or ONE

dddd !!



RAY7

love how Rodney is inching closer and closer in this poll
the real Starz are logging on it seems

Stunna Gor’

Quote from: Hotfuzz07 on August 21, 2020, 08:22:13 PM
Quote from: Harlem on August 21, 2020, 02:13:54 PM
For all those who talking about Afrodisiac sounds cheap, where?!

Afrodisiac does not sound cheap overall but most of the upbeat Timbo tracks (I like them though) are not very inspired imo :

Turn It Up
Saddidy
Come As You Are

and to a lesser extent Who Is She 2 U


Been there, done that
D

!! Very uninspired. I'm adding Afrodisiac and Finally too. Tim simply did not give her quality work, in my eyes.... his best mess wasn't even put on the album. :dead: Y'all can't say these tracks we mentioned are on the same level of quality as Nodding Off and Sirens... :uhh:

I always wished Kanye produced the entire project. The sound, cohesiveness, and quality of his two tracks >>

Afrodisiac as a whole always felt tossed together to me. And it's not even so much about cheap, it lacks cohesiveness to me... which is what I love about Brandy and her bodies of work.

Musicboy88

B7 is one of the trinity??????? I don't know about that lol

Harlem


Bish

Quote from: Trey on August 21, 2020, 09:18:13 PM
Quote from: Hotfuzz07 on August 21, 2020, 08:22:13 PM
Quote from: Harlem on August 21, 2020, 02:13:54 PM
For all those who talking about Afrodisiac sounds cheap, where?!

Afrodisiac does not sound cheap overall but most of the upbeat Timbo tracks (I like them though) are not very inspired imo :

Turn It Up
Saddidy
Come As You Are

and to a lesser extent Who Is She 2 U


Been there, done that
D

!! Very uninspired. I'm adding Afrodisiac and Finally too. Tim simply did not give her quality work, in my eyes.... his best mess wasn't even put on the album. :dead: Y'all can't say these tracks we mentioned are on the same level of quality as Nodding Off and Sirens... :uhh:

I always wished Kanye produced the entire project. The sound, cohesiveness, and quality of his two tracks >>

Afrodisiac as a whole always felt tossed together to me. And it's not even so much about cheap, it lacks cohesiveness to me... which is what I love about Brandy and her bodies of work.
Afro is overrated. I only go back for WYWB, Focus, Necessary, TAOL, Say you will and I tried.

Kanye doing the majority of the album would have been amazing.

Bish

Quote from: Musicboy88 on August 21, 2020, 09:20:56 PM
B7 is one of the trinity??????? I don't know about that lol
B7 is better than Afro to me though. It has the least filler tracks. So for me it is in the trinity.

Bish

Quote from: 𝖘𝖖𝖚𝖎𝖉 on August 20, 2020, 05:32:34 PM
That being said, Timbaland >>>

Most of Rodney's work hasn't aged well
What songs that Rodney did for Brandy sound dated?

Stunna Gor’

Quote from: Bish on August 21, 2020, 10:35:28 PM
Quote from: Trey on August 21, 2020, 09:18:13 PM
Quote from: Hotfuzz07 on August 21, 2020, 08:22:13 PM
Quote from: Harlem on August 21, 2020, 02:13:54 PM
For all those who talking about Afrodisiac sounds cheap, where?!

Afrodisiac does not sound cheap overall but most of the upbeat Timbo tracks (I like them though) are not very inspired imo :

Turn It Up
Saddidy
Come As You Are

and to a lesser extent Who Is She 2 U


Been there, done that
D

!! Very uninspired. I'm adding Afrodisiac and Finally too. Tim simply did not give her quality work, in my eyes.... his best mess wasn't even put on the album. :dead: Y'all can't say these tracks we mentioned are on the same level of quality as Nodding Off and Sirens... :uhh:

I always wished Kanye produced the entire project. The sound, cohesiveness, and quality of his two tracks >>

Afrodisiac as a whole always felt tossed together to me. And it's not even so much about cheap, it lacks cohesiveness to me... which is what I love about Brandy and her bodies of work.
Afro is overrated. I only go back for WYWB, WIS2U, and How I Feel (excluding the bonus tracks, of course)

Kanye doing the majority of the album would have been amazing.
SOOOO overrated. :dead:

!!!!! If Kanye controlled the project, it would've SLAYED. It was a different sound for her, yet he still perfectly captured and executed her essence. It would've been so cohesive. UGHHH!

Vonc2002

Full moon is Brandy's MOST overrated album
This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw





Le Champ

Quote from: Bish on August 21, 2020, 10:37:00 PM
Quote from: Musicboy88 on August 21, 2020, 09:20:56 PM
B7 is one of the trinity??????? I don't know about that lol
B7 is better than Afro to me though. It has the least filler tracks. So for me it is in the trinity.

Wow yea


KYJuvenatiON.

Full Moon is NOT overrated. Y'all need meds. 

Vonc2002

This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw





demitri.petty

How is this a fair discussion? Brandy only has 1 album produced by Timbaland, and several with Rodney. And Rodney has an advantage because he worked with her during each of her peaks as an artist: