I personally feel like beautifully written songs with immaculate instrumentation don't mean a thing when the singer is incapable of breathing life into or immersing themselves into the song.
That could just be me. What do y'all think?
elaborate... i need examples dahhling...
I totally get this.
Ciara's "I found Myself" could have been a beautiful song. The simple instrumentation, the melody, the lyrics..... but the vocal killed what could have been a FORCE behind that song. It just didn't go anywhere.
Is this about Ella Mai ? :guys:
Examples?
Rih is the perfect example that catalog>>>voice
Ddddddd
i need like... REAL examples. Hits. I'm not sure if I'm understanding. But at the end of the day... I guess it's all subjective.
There's a lot of bops made by people who aren't powerhouse singers. You don't need a voice to make a dope song as long as your tone slays.
Quote from: Chokeme Politely on March 27, 2019, 07:24:43 PM
Rih is the perfect example that catalog>>>voice
how I captured what he's saying is that it's not really about vocal "ability"... it's about the artist bringing a certain kind of life to a song that no other artist could. He's arguing that the song is a hit or good just because of the song itself, not anything that the artist did for it.
No one else could do What's My Name, Rude Boy, ect. like Rih.
Quote from: Ulysses on March 27, 2019, 07:19:03 PM
I totally get this.
Ciara's "I found Myself" could have been a beautiful song. The simple instrumentation, the melody, the lyrics..... but the vocal killed what could have been a FORCE behind that song. It just didn't go anywhere.
Ci's lesdo this real quick
Quote from: Trey on March 27, 2019, 07:24:56 PM
Ddddddd
I'm not sure if I'm understanding.
Yeah. You never do
Hhg o shit
Janet Jackson discography
Ssddddddddsdds
not the fumes LEANING into the next thread.
:udontlookok:
It's not like the 2 things are mutually exclusive.
There's plenty of bad singers with good catalogs.
Janet, Rih etc etc.
Quote from: Temper on March 27, 2019, 07:34:09 PM
Janet Jackson discography
KKKKOIIYYYYTTTTYIIOOIUhhhj
Cassie come to mind.
i guess i missed the memo... :mmyulost: when did my auntie janet become a bad singer? she has some of the best background vocals in the industry...
She's not. A certain Stan base got a lil upset
Upset? Boy shut the fuck up and take a leap into a pot of aids for me. Fuckin bitch
See?
Can you see? You and them retinas from the 1920s can sit back. DECAYING ape
This STENCH that overcomes each thread this oldtimer wheels himself into. Why do you even hit post? :plzstop: You don't get a reply from ppl unless you gettin dragged
Log on for a lashing? Sit tight then
Instead of being upset, they should be setting up a streaming party for tomorrow. Can't have 5 consecutive flops
Quote from: Chokeme Politely on March 27, 2019, 07:24:43 PM
Rih is the perfect example that catalog>>>voice
Rih sings DOWN
Quote from: Ulysses on March 27, 2019, 08:17:46 PM
https://www.billboard.com/articles/news/8470665/harmony-samuels-janet-jackson-made-for-now-ep
:'(
I wanna know about this EP lol
what's going on?
Quote from: Temper on March 27, 2019, 08:24:45 PM
I wanna know about this EP lol
what's going on?
jjjksfjndsds
Yeah, plz update us Jans.
Yeah cause I cant take a rihanna song serious.
Sevyn Streeter.......
Not in the way yall talking about... but she's just a waste of hit songs.
Quote from: Temper on March 27, 2019, 08:15:37 PM
This STENCH that overcomes each thread this oldtimer wheels himself into. Why do you even hit post? :plzstop: You don't get a reply from ppl unless you gettin dragged
Log on for a lashing? Sit tight then
bxbxbbxbxbdbxxbxb
That old faggot will avoid real mess until he dies
Which won't be long
Love Queen...
But lowkey, Tinashe... A lot of her mess should've just been given to Rih, Brit, or somebody who would've done a little something with it.
UrbaNEY would've slayed this
Quote from: tontonton on March 27, 2019, 09:53:01 PM
Quote from: Temper on March 27, 2019, 08:15:37 PM
This STENCH that overcomes each thread this oldtimer wheels himself into. Why do you even hit post? :plzstop: You don't get a reply from ppl unless you gettin dragged
Log on for a lashing? Sit tight then
bxbxbbxbxbdbxxbxb
That old faggot will avoid real mess until he dies
Which won't be long
I'm absolutely disgusted. Let's hide ha dentures!
Ladies. I really didn't mean to upset you. I alpologize. I didn't think naming a Ciara song with a horrid vocal would drive y'all so damn crazy. In fact, imma help the Ci's and help start a streaming party for "Thinkin' Bout you". Lemme go start a thread..:
m
Faggot nobody is reading that pathetic apology
Never met a more passive aggressive weak nigger
Just don't die that way, okay? LMAO
Woo! Sorry I upset ya!
Nigger was anyone talking about Ci the last 300 times you mentioned her?
No
So I'm upset you felt compelled to mention her in random conversations
You need some dick
Goodnight King
sdsdsdsdsdsdsdsdssdsdsdsdsdsdsdsdsdsddsdsscccvvcvc
Guys... I was actually enjoying this topic.
:omgwatshappening:
And start the thread so I can terrorize you every fucking day
I need a home to lash you since you like to be cute and random
I've been stanning for queen for 15 years
I can go another 15 lolz
Btw I saw your pics
Yuck
Lis and I kiid down
Ton really STEPPED on this roach ass bitch ass :kii:
Quote from: tontonton on March 27, 2019, 10:19:31 PM
And start the thread so I can terrorize you every fucking day
I need a home to lash you since you like to be cute and random
:plzstop:
The catalog is separate from the talent
It takes more than talent to create something special
Jhuds slave wails will never see britney spears catalog
Yes imo. You don't need to be the best singer to make good music. Look at Madonna, Janet, Britney
Not a Tranet fan talking about vocals going nowhere.
hasnt that thing whispered her entire mess?
Quote from: Jonovan on March 28, 2019, 01:21:10 AM
Yes imo. You don't need to be the best singer to make good music. Look at Madonna, Janet, Britney
girl shut up
madonna sang in the 80s
+ there's more emotion in ray of light than there is in mariah's entire discography
and to answer the question
I'd take britney of xtinct anyday
and cassie over jdud anyday.
so no, it doesn't matter.
Quote from: Jonovan on March 28, 2019, 01:21:10 AM
Yes imo. You don't need to be the best singer to make good music. Look at Madonna, Janet, Britney
Quote from: Temper on March 27, 2019, 08:09:04 PM
Upset? Boy shut the fuck up and take a leap into a pot of aids for me. Fuckin bitch
ssssssssssgvd
Quote from: tontonton on March 27, 2019, 10:18:16 PM
Woo! Sorry I upset ya!
Nigger was anyone talking about Ci the last 300 times you mentioned her?
No
So I'm upset you felt compelled to mention her in random conversations
You need some dick
Goodnight King
jjjjjjt]] :guys: