Home

[zaiye9837]

I personally feel like beautifully written songs with immaculate instrumentation don't mean a thing when the singer is incapable of breathing life into or immersing themselves into the song.

That could just be me. What do y'all think?

[THE_FIRST_LADY]

elaborate... i need examples dahhling...

[Ulysses]

I totally get this. 

Ciara's "I found Myself" could have been a beautiful song. The simple instrumentation, the melody, the lyrics..... but the vocal killed what could have been a FORCE behind that song. It just didn't go anywhere. 

[BAPHOMET.]

Is this about Ella Mai ? 

[BigDawg]

Examples?

[CHOKE]

Rih is the perfect example that catalog>>>voice

[Stunna Gor’]

Ddddddd

i need like... REAL examples. Hits. I'm not sure if I'm understanding. But at the end of the day... I guess it's all subjective.

[garlic]

There's a lot of bops made by people who aren't powerhouse singers. You don't need a voice to make a dope song as long as your tone slays.

[Stunna Gor’]

Rih is the perfect example that catalog>>>voice

how I captured what he's saying is that it's not really about vocal "ability"... it's about the artist bringing a certain kind of life to a song that no other artist could. He's arguing that the song is a hit or good just because of the song itself, not anything that the artist did for it.

No one else could do What's My Name, Rude Boy, ect. like Rih.

[...my little hiatus]

I totally get this.

Ciara's "I found Myself" could have been a beautiful song. The simple instrumentation, the melody, the lyrics..... but the vocal killed what could have been a FORCE behind that song. It just didn't go anywhere.

Ci's lesdo this real quick

[Scott.]

Ddddddd

I'm not sure if I'm understanding.

Yeah. You never do

[...my little hiatus]

Hhg o shit

[fedswatchin]

Janet Jackson discography

[Stunna Gor’]

Ssddddddddsdds

not the fumes LEANING into the next thread.

[Nine]

It's not like the 2 things are mutually exclusive.

There's plenty of bad singers with good catalogs.

Janet, Rih etc etc.