Would y’all say Mariah and Whitney were a tie vocally?

Started by Hatsumomo, May 19, 2021, 08:33:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

FRANCE

Mariah is more versatile tho I will say. She can give me soft (Underneath The Stars / GTFO), vocal stacking (The Roof), wide upper range (Butterfly), deep low notes (You and I), insane melisma and transitions (Heartbreaker). She can give me hip hop, sexy, some of the things Whitney doesnt really give. So I can see why some folks will say MC is better to them.

Cartierline

Quote from: FRANCE on May 20, 2021, 10:04:02 AM
Mariah is more versatile tho I will say. She can give me soft (Underneath The Stars / GTFO), vocal stacking (The Roof), wide upper range (Butterfly), deep low notes (You and I), insane melisma and transitions (Heartbreaker). She can give me hip hop, sexy, some of the things Whitney doesnt really give. So I can see why some folks will say MC is better to them.
I can agree with this.
It ties in to Mariah being a better artist. Whit' couldn't pull off all of the concepts Mariah did.

RAY7

I mean Whit has Gospel albums, Pop albums, R&B albums. They both have done things the other hasnt

Vonc2002

This wasnt discussed but whitney is also cuter than that pie faced hoe
This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw





FRANCE

Mariah's voice got shot in 8 years after her debut too. Whitney held up her voice for much longer. 

JCJ

Quote from: bby ddy on May 20, 2021, 09:39:17 AM
Whitney was the better singer and performer. Everything about her was naturally captivating.

best selling female rapper of all time

Vonc2002

This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw





Vonc2002

Quote from: FRANCE on May 20, 2021, 10:49:05 AM
Mariah's voice got shot in 8 years after her debut too. Whitney held up her voice for much longer.
I always say this. By the time butterfly came out mariah was really just a run of the mill type singer
This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw






Plastic.



best selling female rapper of all time



Vonc2002

This is my pass to say WHATEVER tf I wanna say about the mess she releases so I don't wanna hear SHIT! Baby mama is a mess of a song btw





bby ddy

This sweet, seductive, quiet storm ass fckn vocal  :wub:






If given the chance, Whitney COULD have dug deeper into her R&B bag. She wasn't some one-dimensional J.Hud screamy type vocalist.

RAY7

Quote from: bby ddy on May 20, 2021, 11:22:28 AM
This sweet, seductive, quiet storm ass fckn vocal  :wub:






If given the chance, Whitney COULD have dug deeper into her R&B bag. She wasn't some one-dimensional J.Hud screamy type vocalist.
her tone is soooooo beautiful